The Injury That Has Upended the Women’s World Cup
Some of the best players in the world have gone down with A.C.L. tears—an injury that, for reasons which aren’t entirely clear, women experience far more often than men.It is no surprise that England is in the final of the Women’s World Cup. They are the world’s fourth-ranked team, the reigning European champions, and were among the semifinalists at the World Cup four years ago. The final was the expectation, not the goal. When England dominated Germany in the Euro finals last September, there were more than eighty-seven thousand fans at Wembley Stadium. England beat the United States at a friendly a month later, and some seventy-seven thousand people came to watch.And yet that team is not this one. The revelation of that roster was Beth Mead, who established herself as an almost unstoppable force in a dazzling display at the Euros, winning the Golden Boot for most goals and the Golden Ball for the tournament’s best player. In November, she tore her A.C.L. A few months later, England’s captain, Leah Williamson, bent her leg awkwardly as she came over the ball on a challenge in a game for her club team, Arsenal. Face down on the field, she threw up a hand to signal for help, then pounded the earth in obvious pain and frustration. Surely, she knew, even then—before she limped from the pitch, supported by medics; before the MRI confirmed the grim diagnosis; before the surgery—that she’d torn her A.C.L. Everyone knew. Everyone had seen it happen too many times before.In early May, the England midfielder Fran Kirby, a two-time F.A. player of the year, announced that she, too, would be undergoing surgery to repair an injured knee, and would miss the World Cup. And the tournament had hardly started when Keira Walsh, the team’s fulcrum in the midfield, went down with a leg injury. “I’ve done my knee,” she reportedly told medical staff as she was carried away on a stretcher. When it was announced that her A.C.L. was, in fact, still intact, and that she would be able to return—in the end, she missed only a game and a half—the news was presented as a kind of miracle.Even without these players, England is still a phenomenal team. It overcame a surging Australia—propelled by the passion of the home country’s fans and the unstoppable force of Sam Kerr—with ruthless, clinical play, despite missing yet another star: the dynamite young forward Lauren James, who had to sit out for two games after receiving a red card for stomping on a Nigerian player, Michelle Alozie. But England has been gritting out wins, not racing to them. It’s tempting to wonder what the team would look like if not for the rash of ligament ruptures.But you could say that of several teams. England is far from the only one dealing with A.C.L. injuries. The Netherlands, last year’s finalist, might have gone further than the quarterfinals if they’d had their best player, Vivianne Miedema, who tore her A.C.L. last winter. The United States’ inability to score goals is less shocking when you consider that Catarina Macario, perhaps their best player, was out with a torn A.C.L. (Their top goal scorer in 2023, Mallory Swanson, missed the tournament, too, with a torn patellar tendon.) Canada, the reigning Olympic champions, lost their star forward, Janine Beckie, to an A.C.L. tear in March. France’s Marie-Antoinette Katoto, a nominee for the 2022 Ballon d’Or, tore her A.C.L. last year. Her French teammate Delphine Cascarino tore hers in May. The list goes on. Myriad factors have played into the chaos and surprise of this World Cup—none of the four semifinalists has ever won the championship—but the ripple effect of A.C.L. injuries is one of the biggest. You might even call it a crisis—if it were anything new.The anterior cruciate ligament is a thick band of tissue connecting the thigh bone (the femur) to the shinbone (the tibia). It’s found inside the knee joint, in front of the posterior cruciate ligament (P.C.L.), which it crosses to form a kind of sturdy “X.” The A.C.L. keeps the shinbone from sliding in front of the thigh bone and keeps the knee in place. But when it is stressed in certain ways—during a quick pivot, for instance, or an awkward landing or sudden impact—it can rip. When that happens, the knee loses stability. After a full rupture, it generally won’t regenerate or heal on its own. Instead, doctors will take a portion of the patient’s hamstring, quadriceps, or patellar tendon, or tissue from an organ donor, and graft it into the knee to create a new A.C.L.This can work well, particularly if you have access to top-flight doctors, as most professional athletes do. But it is painful, and recovery is long and arduous. It’s expensive, too, if you’re footing the bill: out-of-pocket costs in the U.S. can be upward of ten thousand dollars. Full recovery can take anywhere from nine months to more than a year—an eternity in the short life of an élite athlete. Even when an athlete regains most of her form, the reconstructed knee can be vulnerable. A significant percentage of athletes who have torn their A.C.L. once do it again within a few years. Around half develop osteoarthritis five to fifteen years after surgery. People who tear their A.C.L.s are around seven times more likely to need a total knee replacement down the road. And, no matter how common the surgery has become, the healing process can be unpredictable. Christen Press, a key player on the U.S. team that won the 2019 World Cup, recently underwent her fourth operation on a knee that she tore up last year.Male athletes tear their A.C.L.s, too, in alarming numbers—in the Premier League earlier this month, Jurrien Timber had barely stepped on the field after a flashy, forty-million-dollar transfer to Arsenal when he damaged his. But the rate is significantly higher among female athletes, particularly in sports that involve sudden stops, pivots, and accelerations. Just how much higher is unclear. (Kathryn Ackerman, a doctor specializing in sports medicine—she runs the Wu Tsai Female Athlete Program at Boston Children’s Hospital—told me that women are four to six times more likely than men to tear their A.C.L.s.) Why there is such a difference is not entirely clear, either. There are morphological factors: women often have a smaller notch on their femurs than men, which gives the ligament less leeway when stretched; they typically have wider hips, which changes the angle of the femur. Women tend to have stronger quadriceps relative to their hamstrings, and to land more flat-footed and with stiffer knees. There is a strong suspicion that menstrual cycles increase the risk of ruptures, by affecting ligament laxity, but, as is the case with so many medical issues affecting women, the theory has not been the subject of sufficient rigorous study.Still, biology is not destiny, and for too long it was treated as such. The Football Association, English soccer’s governing body, banned women’s teams in 1921, stating “the game of football is quite unsuitable for females and ought not to be encouraged.” The ban was not lifted until 1970. A narrow focus on how the morphology of women affects injury rates not only runs the risk of deterring girls from competing in the first place; it also threatens to reinforce the false idea that sports are unsuitable for women, while ignoring crucial social and cultural factors. For decades, women have often played on inferior fields, which is known to increase the risk of non-contact leg injuries. (This was a sticking point for the U.S. women’s national team in their fight for equal pay and conditions.) They have played without sufficient medical infrastructure or training support. They have participated in training programs that are insufficient for their needs. As opportunities and access have expanded, the quality of their environment hasn’t quite kept pace.England’s domestic league wasn’t fully professional until five years ago. Since then, traditional powerhouses—Chelsea, Arsenal, Manchester City, Manchester United, and so on—have begun investing more of their resources and influence in the women’s game, to tremendous effect. Now England’s women’s league and national team both occupy spaces in the upper echelon of international sport. The teams have legitimate television contracts with the BBC and Sky Sports, and receive continual coverage from places like the Guardian and the Athletic. Increasingly, the stars are superstars. The schedule has grown along with demand; players are playing more, and with greater intensity. But that extra load on their legs has consequences. And, even now, at all levels, women’s teams are more likely than men’s teams to travel by coach instead of business class, commercial instead of charter. A National Women’s Soccer League game was once played on a fifty-eight-yard-wide field in a Triple-A baseball stadium. Women typically wear cleats made from molds of men’s feet, and that shape affects how arches and heels are supported when an athlete lands. (This could be especially significant when it comes to A.C.L.s, given the way that perilous ground-foot interactions can stress the knee.) They are often, even at the élite level, supported by smaller medical staff, with less training, than the men receive.The disparity in resources extends down through the youth levels. That, in fact, is where some of the biggest problems are. For all the attention that A.C.L. injuries among élite players are getting, many of the hundreds of thousands that occur each year happen to younger players. Generally, girls are at high risk of A.C.L. injuries after they have gone through puberty but before they have built up their strength. The first time that the U.S. national team member Emily Fox tore her A.C.L., she was a freshman in college. Megan Rapinoe tore hers three times, the first as a college sophomore. Alex Morgan tore hers in high school. And they are the lucky ones: many younger athletes, who don’t have the access to doctors and rehabilitation programs that top athletes do—or who are simply, and understandably, traumatized by their injury—quit the sport they were playing when they were hurt. Some quit sports altogether.
The Premier League Needs Harry Kane To Be A Success At Bayern Munich
Harry Kane’s Bayern Munich debut couldn’t have gone much worse. The England capt ...
Read more
England's women are outshining men on the football pitch – and in the commentary box too | Simon O'Hagan
When it comes to describing the action, the BBC’s Robyn Cowen is a master of the ...
Read more
Mitrovic set to complete Al Hilal move | Silva: He forced everything to leave
Aleksandar Mitrovic is travelling to Saudi Arabia to complete a deal in excess o ...
Read more
Fulham receive club-record fee as Mitrovic makes Al Hilal move
Aleksandar Mitrovic has joined Saudi Arabian side Al Hilal in a club-record deal ...
Read more
England’s Lionesses have restored joy to the beautiful game – but for how long? | Emma John
Players and bosses have held themselves to higher standards than their male coun ...
Read more
Josh Pugh spearheads England’s partially sighted team at World Games | Ben Fisher
Comedian was ‘Beckham-mad’ and says playing for partially sighted team ‘is hard, ...
Read more
Where to find Tottenham vs Man United on US TV
Here are all of the details of where you can watch Tottenham vs Man United on US ...
Read more
Where to find Liverpool vs Bournemouth on US TV
Here are all of the details of where you can watch Liverpool vs Bournemouth on U ...
Read more
Dortmund, West Ham chasing Man City starlet Palmer
Manchester City manager Pep Guardiola has a major dilemma on his hands regarding ...
Read more
Tottenham vs. Manchester United prediction, odds, start time: 2023 English Premier League picks for Aug. 19
SportsLine soccer expert Jon Eimer has locked in his EPL picks, predictions and ...
Read more
Australia vs. Sweden odds, start time: Soccer expert reveals Women's World Cup picks, third-place game bets
SportsLine soccer expert Martin Green locked in his FIFA Women's World Cup 2023 ...
Read more
Clinical Brentford win 3-0 at 10-man Fulham
LONDON: Yoane Wissa and Bryan Mbeumo fired Brentford to a 3-0 win at Fulham in t ...
Read more
Man Utd owners the Glazers briefed on fan backlash after making stance on shares clear
The Glazer family have been in discussions surrounding the part, or full sale of ...
Read more
PIX: Liverpool script comeback win; Brighton go top
IMAGES from the English Premier League matches played on Saturday. ...
Read more
Manchester City vs. Newcastle - Preview, Lineups & Talking Points
Current Champs vs. Future Champs in the Gulf State Derby ...
Read more
What can Aston Villa fans expect from Nicolò Zaniolo? Galatasaray fans gives us the lowdown on Unai Emery’s latest signing
With the signing of Nicolò Zaniolo now confirmed by Aston Villa, fans will be lo ...
Read more
TRANSFER GOSSIP: Chelsea hold talks to sign Arsenal star Folarin Balogun, Fiorentina say they have not had a bid from Man United for Sofyan Amrabat and Everton edge closer to a new striker
In rather dramatic circumstances, Mauricio Pochettino's side snatched Caicedo an ...
Read more
'I even had the Becks mohican!': JWP and the anatomy of a free-kick
In his Southampton farewell video, there was a clip of a teenage James Ward-Prow ...
Read more
Former Arsenal defender Konstantinos Mavropanos 'not called up' for Stuttgart game as West Ham move edges closer after deal for Harry Maguire collapses
The Greek defender is expected to travel to London for a medical in the next 24 ...
Read more
Tyler Adams passes his Bournemouth medical and is set to sign contract with the Cherries ahead of £20million move to the Premier League club
The Stars and Stripes captain underwent his medical Friday and is now set to put ...
Read more
10-man Liverpool pick up first win of the season
Jurgen Klopp’s side were too good for Bournemouth. ...
Read more
Steven Gerrard and Al-Ettifaq players celebrate second successive league victory dancing and signing in the dressing room as his side go joint-top of the Saudi Pro League
The former Liverpool midfielder, who took charge of the Pro League club earlier ...
Read more
Liverpool recover from rocky opening to see off Bournemouth
Reds also had a man sent off at Anfield. ...
Read more
Edinson Cavani Is Key For Boca Juniors
Star signing Edinson Cavani scores his first goal for new club Boca Juniors as t ...
Read more
German newspapers laud Harry Kane's Bundesliga debut at Bayern Munich after the £100m man finds the net against Werder Bremen - as Bild leads with their back page headline: 'Yes, he Kane!'
Kane got his Bundesliga career off to the perfect start with a goal and an assis ...
Read more
AD FEATURE: Paddy Power welcome offer: Get £20 back as cash if your Women's World Cup Final bet loses
Sign up for the Paddy Power welcome offer below and get your bet back as cash up ...
Read more
Revealed: The stunning honour that awaits the Matildas after their World Cup playoff for third against Sweden
Skipper Sam Kerr and her teammates have lifted the whole country with their stun ...
Read more
Man Utd 'considering Mason Greenwood U-turn' after fierce online backlash
Mason Greenwood, 21, has not played for Manchester United since January 2022, wi ...
Read more
The Premier League Needs Harry Kane To Be A Success At Bayern Munich
The challenge for Kane won’t necessarily be settling into the Bayern Munich team ...
Read more
Catching Up With Former Utes: Steve Smith Sr.
“If you see this face, that means I scored,” “Ice up, son,” these are some of th ...
Read more
Kane Scores On Bundesliga Debut As Bayern Munish Beat Werder Bremen
England striker Harry Kane admitted he was "nervous" on his Bayern Munich debut, ...
Read more
Pep Guardiola reveals he chose Man City's penalty-takers ahead of their winning Super Cup shootout on Wednesday - learning from his mistake after letting the players decide and losing to Arsenal in the Community Shield
The CIty boss took responsibility for selecting City's kick-takers against Sevil ...
Read more
Manchester United cult hero Henning Berg tells FFT the moment in his career that his kids tease him over
Manchester United took on Real Madrid in 2000 – and Henning Berg's kids will rem ...
Read more
Liverpool 3-1 Bournemouth: Alexis Mac Allister red card should be 'discussed', says Jurgen Klopp
Liverpool manager Jurgen Klopp believes Alexis Mac Allister's red card should be ...
Read more
Tottenham legend Ledley King describes his training regime during the height of the knee injury that ended his career
Tottenham cult hero Ledley King has told FourFourTwo about the crazy training re ...
Read more
When is transfer Deadline Day?
So with business in the final throws, when is transfer Deadline Day? Here are al ...
Read more
The Injury That Has Upended the Women’s World Cup
Some of the best players in the world have gone down with A.C.L. tears—an injury ...
Read more
How to watch the free Tottenham vs Manchester United live stream
One of today’s late Premier League games is Tottenham vs Manchester, and we've g ...
Read more
March scores two as Brighton win at Wolves
A stunning solo goal from Kaoru Mitoma and a second-half double from Solly March ...
Read more
Liverpool overcome sloppy start and Alexis Mac Allister red card to beat Bournemouth
Liverpool overcame a torrid start and a red card for Alexis Mac Allister to beat ...
Read more
Steven Gerrard and Al-Ettifaq players celebrate second successive league victory dancing and signing in the dressing room as his side go joint-top of the Saudi Pro League
The former Liverpool midfielder, who took charge of the Pro League club earlier ...
Read more
Mohamed Salah breaks new Liverpool record after Steven Gerrard's "embarrassed" admission
The Liverpool talisman is now above Steven Gerrard in the Reds' all-time scoring ...
Read more
Premier League: Aston Villa v Everton - team news & build-up
Follow live text and radio commentary as Aston Villa face Everton in the Premier ...
Read more
Wolverhampton Wanderers 1-4 Brighton & Hove Albion: Superb Seagulls cruise to victory at Molineux
A stunning solo goal from Kaoru Mitoma and a second-half double from Solly March ...
Read more
Koalas, swearing and hijabs: unmissable Women’s World Cup moments
Read more
Who are the BBC World Cup commentators? Alex Scott, Ellen White and full list of pundits
Read more
Where to find West Ham vs Chelsea on US TV
Read more
Where to find Aston Villa vs Everton on US TV
Read more
Preview: Crystal Palace v Arsenal
Read more
11 times politicians have jumped on football bandwagon and it's backfired
Read more
England boss Sarina Wiegman insists her side are 'ready' for the World Cup final - as Lionesses coach sends final rallying message ahead of Spain clash
Read more
Ex-Man Utd star tells own club they need to sack him and find new manager
Read more
How Manchester United cult hero Henning Berg only came to England thanks to a medical mixup: now the Norwegian shares the crazy story
Read more
Neymar gets a fleet of cars and THREE saunas, Gareth Bale flew in a private jet once used by the Queen and Paul Gascoigne's sister's sunbed! Football's wildest contract demands
Read more
Rachel Daly's inspiration: Star Lioness plays in honour of her late father Martyn who passed away suddenly from sepsis in 2021
Read more
Former Lionesses captain Carol Thomas recalls winning 'unofficial World Cup' of 1985 as England face Spain for the greatest prize today
Read more
Inside Lionesses' luxury holiday escapes and family lives away from football
Read more
Spain v England: Best bets for Sunday's World Cup Final and Premier League games
Read more
Gareth Southgate tells England women they 'have done more than us already' as the men's head coach delivers his support to the Lionesses
Read more
TV tonight: Stormzy’s phenomenal live set in east London
Read more
Claims Newcastle United’s Eddie Howe Is Pep Guardiola’s Equal Are Lunacy
Read more
Rachel Daly's inspiration: Star Lioness plays in honour of her late father Martyn who passed away suddenly from sepsis in 2021
Read more
How Ella Toone silenced the haters: Scoring crucial goals is the ideal way to answer critics for the England striker after her thunderbolt strike against Australia
Read more
England boss Sarina Wiegman sends final rallying message before Spain showdown, insisting 'we know what our game plan is' and declares: 'we are ready'
Read more
Lionesses star Alex Greenwood is dating ex-Premier League ace forced to retire aged 29
Read more
Man Utd transfer round-up: Maguire's West Ham snub explained as Bailly holds Fulham talks
Read more
Pep Guardiola praises Phil Foden’s versatility as Manchester City win again
Read more
Everton at Aston Villa: kickoff time, starting lineups, TV schedule, live stream and how to watch online
Read more
Everton at Aston Villa: Opposition Analysis | Smash and Grab?
Read more
Protective boot just a precaution – James Maddison plays down ankle injury
Read more
Where to find Aston Villa vs Everton on US TV
Read more
Who are the BBC World Cup commentators? Alex Scott, Ellen White and full list of pundits
Read more
Koalas, swearing and hijabs: unmissable Women’s World Cup moments
Read more
TV tonight: Stormzy’s phenomenal live set in east London
Read more
Inside Lionesses' luxury holiday escapes and family lives away from football
Read more
Where to find West Ham vs Chelsea on US TV
Read more
Preview: Crystal Palace v Arsenal
Read more
Gareth Southgate tells England women they 'have done more than us already' as the men's head coach delivers his support to the Lionesses
Read more
How Ella Toone silenced the haters: Scoring crucial goals is the ideal way to answer critics for the England striker after her thunderbolt strike against Australia
Read more
11 times politicians have jumped on football bandwagon and it's backfired
Read more
Everton at Aston Villa: Opposition Analysis | Smash and Grab?
Read more
Claims Newcastle United’s Eddie Howe Is Pep Guardiola’s Equal Are Lunacy
Read more
Rachel Daly's inspiration: Star Lioness plays in honour of her late father Martyn who passed away suddenly from sepsis in 2021
Read more
Lionesses star Alex Greenwood is dating ex-Premier League ace forced to retire aged 29
Read more
Neymar gets a fleet of cars and THREE saunas, Gareth Bale flew in a private jet once used by the Queen and Paul Gascoigne's sister's sunbed! Football's wildest contract demands
Read more
A week of ups and downs in the UK economy
Read more
Man Utd transfer round-up: Maguire's West Ham snub explained as Bailly holds Fulham talks
Read more
Ex-Man Utd star tells own club they need to sack him and find new manager
Read more
Protective boot just a precaution – James Maddison plays down ankle injury
Read more
Spain v England: Best bets for Sunday's World Cup Final and Premier League games
Read more
Former Lionesses captain Carol Thomas recalls winning 'unofficial World Cup' of 1985 as England face Spain for the greatest prize today
Read more
Rachel Daly's inspiration: Star Lioness plays in honour of her late father Martyn who passed away suddenly from sepsis in 2021
Read more
England boss Sarina Wiegman insists her side are 'ready' for the World Cup final - as Lionesses coach sends final rallying message ahead of Spain clash
Read more
England boss Sarina Wiegman sends final rallying message before Spain showdown, insisting 'we know what our game plan is' and declares: 'we are ready'
Read more
Everton at Aston Villa: kickoff time, starting lineups, TV schedule, live stream and how to watch online
Read more
How Manchester United cult hero Henning Berg only came to England thanks to a medical mixup: now the Norwegian shares the crazy story
Read more
Pep Guardiola praises Phil Foden’s versatility as Manchester City win again
Read more
Quick Links